To acquire this achievement, the player must get their criminal rating to the Godfather rating.
The easiest method for earning this achievement is to play the Vigilante mode using the Hunter that spawns at Fort Baxter Air Base. The mode has an unlimited number of levels that progressively earn the player more and more money with each level. After about an hour of persistent gameplay, the player should be around level 150 and earning nearly $1,000,000 per level. Checking the Stats menu will also show that the Criminal Rating is growing exponentially. Around level 200, the player should earn the achievement for reaching 100,000 Criminal Rating.
- The name of the achievement is a reference to Peter Clemenza's line "Leave the gun, take the cannoli" from the 1972 movie The Godfather.
- In the retired PlayStation 4 version, this was a Gold trophy, but in the Definitive Edition, it is a Silver trophy.