|This mission crosses over with Diamonds Are a Girl's Best Friend.|
- Tony: "We're getting Gracie back. She's coming home."
- Luis: "You mean we're taking her back, or is this gonna be tranquilo?"
- Tony: "God, I hope so. They're getting the diamonds for her, so they better behave."
- —Tony telling Luis about exchanging the diamonds for the release of Gracie Ancelotti.
Luis meets Brucie and Roman in front of Maisonette 9 as they are trying to enter the club. Luis grants them entry and he meets with Tony. Tony explains that Giovanni Ancelotti has ordered Tony and Luis to rescue his daughter, or he'll have them both killed. Tony has arranged a meet with her kidnappers, Niko Bellic and Patrick McReary. Luis initially suggests giving the diamonds to Bulgarin, but Tony points out that they have a better chance against Bulgarin than they do with Ancelotti.
The duo head to Pier 45 and take a boat to Charge Island where they meet Niko and Patrick. Luis gives them the diamonds and they return Gracie, but the trio are attacked by Bulgarin's men. They escape on the boat and head back to Pier 45. Gracie threatens Luis for not killing Niko and Patrick and threatens to have them killed, before Luis knocks her out. At Pier 45, Luis gets off the boat while Tony leaves to return Gracie to her father.
In order to complete the mission, the player must:
- Get in Tony's car
- Go to Pier 45
- Go to the Charge Island Sewage Works
- Shake the gang member off the boat
- Go back to Pier 45
Complete the mission in 3:55
Shake off the Russian mobster in seven seconds
The reward for completing the mission is $5000 and the penultimate mission, Party's Over, is unlocked. However, the player will be unable to complete Club Management missions until the end of the game, as both Maisonette 9 and Hercules are closed.
- In Grand Theft Auto IV, Patrick's Vincent is dark green. In this mission, it is black.
- When Luis and Tony are untying Gracie, the player can hear the conversation between Bulgarin and Niko in the background.
- Like in the original GTA IV, Packie uses an Assault Rifle in this mission, while Niko uses a Carbine Rifle.
- In the second line of dialogue should the player replay the mission after a first failed attempt, Tony will say that Old Man Ancelotti made him "an offer he couldn't refuse" and that "one man's tradition is another man's worn out cliche". This is an obvious reference to quote from the 1969 mob book and and it's 1972 film adaptation The Godfather where the character Corlene tells his godson "I'll make him an offer he can't refuse".
- Packie and Niko can be killed. However, their deaths are not canon and they have a colossal amount of health.