The movie tells the story of Danny, a young teenager who goes on a killing spree, and is rated "R for Retarded". A line in the trailer, "I didn't know it was hockey season", appears to pay reference to the Friday the 13th films, where the main antagonist wears a hockey mask. On Pressing Issues, Jan Brown mentions that she won't let her children watch the movie. The film is advertised on the radio and has its own tagline and rating.
Male Narrator: He was just the boy next door…
Old Male (in Southern accent): Hi, well hello there, Danny! I didn’t know it was hockey season...
Danny: Hey, can I borrow a knife?
Male Narrator: A deadly curse, a deranged killer, a small town in tears! Knife After Dark, rated R for Retarded.
- A movie synopses on the in-game website Classicvinewood.com in Grand Theft Auto V claims that Knife After Dark was inspired by the movie Butchery And Other Hobbies.
- The line, "I didn't know it was hockey season..." from the Knife After Dark radio advertisement, while an obvious reference to Jason Vorhees from the Friday the 13th film franchise, may also be a reference to the 1988 remake of The Blob — in that film, several characters are shown watching a fictional horror film in a movie theatre featuring a hedge trimmer-wielding, hockey mask-wearing psychotic killer. When one of the killer's victims sees him, he comments, "I thought hockey season ended months ago?"
- Twilight Knife - A 1980s slasher film that was released two years before Knife After Dark, during the events of Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories.